Choosing Between Liquid Ring Vacuum & Dry Screw Pumps

“Pick the right tool for the job” is an old adage, but it is one that still applies to vacuum technology. No industrial vacuum technologies are the same or work best for all applications.

A critical decision often faced in process industry applications is the choice between liquid ring vacuum pumps or dry screw pumps. Selecting the right vacuum pump will ensure smooth and efficient operation, maximize return on investment (ROI) and improve reliability.

Figure 1. Graphic illustration of dry screw vacuum pump technology

Design & Operation

Dry screw and liquid ring vacuum pumps are rotating positive displacement pumps, but they have differences. The dry vacuum pump does not use fluids to create a vacuum, while the liquid ring does.

Dry screw pumps create a vacuum through the rotation of two screw rotors, arranged in parallel, rotating in opposite directions. The rotors enclose or trap the gas on the inlet side and deliver it to the high-pressure side or gas discharge. During the compression process, the rotors do not contact each other. As a result, there is no need for lubrication or operating fluids in the compression chamber, which is why this is referred to as “dry” technology.

The dry screw uses an internal gearbox, which requires lubrication. It is not uncommon for this lubricant to migrate into the pumping chamber over time, somewhat negating the “dry” claim of this technology.

In a liquid ring pump, a cylindrical housing is partially filled with sealing liquid, and a multiblade impeller on a shaft is positioned eccentrically within the housing. A liquid ring is created by the rotating impeller’s centrifugal force.

This force holds the liquid ring against the inner wall of the pumping chamber.

Because the impeller is located eccentric to the pumping chamber, the depth of entry of the blades into the liquid ring decreases and increases as the impeller rotates. This creates increasing impeller cell volume on the inlet port side, forming a vacuum. On the discharge side, the impeller cell volume decreases as the blades move further into the liquid ring, increasing the pressure until discharge takes place through the discharge port.

The inherent design of the liquid ring pump allows it to use a variety of liquids as the sealant, including water, solvents, oil or other process-compatible fluids. Because the liquid is in contact with the process gas/vapors being compressed, the gas compression is considered nearly isothermal. Final discharge temperatures between 45 and 150 F are controlled and typical in process applications depending on conditions. By controlling the discharge temperature of the liquid ring pump, different gases can be either condensed or passed through, offering great flexibility.

Screw vacuum pumps can be constant-pitch design, in which the gas/vapor is transported at constant volume to the discharge where the majority of compression takes place, or progressive-pitch design, where the gas/vapor is compressed while transporting to the discharge port. In either case, compression is considered adiabatic, with discharge temperatures as high as 450 F. Such high temperatures can cause safety concerns with this technology.

Table 1. Checklist of operating characteristics for process conditions (Graphics courtesy of DEKKER Vacuum Technologies)

Selecting the Vacuum Pump

Typical process vacuum compression applications include degassing, distillation, stripping, drying, evaporation, solvent recovery, crystallization, filtration, vapor recovery, waste gas compression, gas boosters and reactor service.

Many of the gas/vapor streams typically being compressed in the process industries are explosive, toxic, corrosive, reactive, and wet or saturated. The first step in evaluating which vacuum technology to use is to eliminate pumping systems that cannot meet the process conditions, including vacuum level, capacity, gas inlet temperature and discharge pressure (see Table 1).

Step 2 in the evaluation process is a review of operating characteristics when compressing process gas/vapor streams (see Table 2).

Table 2. Checklist of operating characteristics when compressing gas/vapor streams

Step 3 in the evaluation is to consider the effects of process gas/vapor contamination (see Table 3).

Table 3. Checklist of operating characteristics for process gas/vapor contamination

Liquid ring pumps can take on the dirtiest processes. They have a high tolerance for harsh environments, aggressive saturated air and/or vapor loads. The liquid ring vacuum pump and compressor also act as a direct-contact condenser. When handling high condensable vapor loads, these elements condense inside the liquid ring and increase pumping efficiency, resulting in increased pumping speed over the performance curve (cubic feet per minute/horsepower).

Dry screw vacuum pumps should be considered when applied to relatively dry clean gas streams and when no process contamination can be tolerated.

Because of the deeper partial vacuum levels achieved, this machine should be considered when vacuum levels under 10 torr are being considered, although multistage liquid ring systems are used in these applications as well.

Liquid ring designs have only one moving part: the impeller/shaft assembly. In these designs, bearings are external to the pumping chamber and there is no metal-to-metal contact between the rotating parts and the casing.

With these design characteristics, liquid ring pumps are easy to maintain and service. In general industrial applications, oil-sealed liquid ring machines can operate for 10,000 hours or more without an oil change, and changing oil is simple and inexpensive—technicians and expensive contracts are not required.

Dry screw pumps require changing lubricants in the gear chambers and, because of tight internal clearances, can require expensive inlet filtration systems that must be maintained. Complete overhauls of dry screw pumps can be complex and expensive.

Because liquid ring pumps have fluid in the chamber, operate at speeds of 1,800 revolutions per minute (rpm) or less, and have no metal-to-metal contact, they are among the quietest pumps in the industry.

Typical liquid ring sound levels are between 75 and 78 decibels, and they do not require expensive sound enclosures.

The wisest strategy a manufacturer can use to “pick the right tool for the job” in this situation is to consult with a vacuum pump specialist. Experience and expertise can help determine the best possible vacuum technology for any specific application.

Users looking for advantages and maximum ROI can rely on major pump manufacturers to continue research and development using state-of-the-art technology and software to create innovations in liquid ring and dry screw vacuum pumps to make them more efficient, more durable, and capable of handling more process as well as general industrial applications.