The closed loop differential pump uses linear drives that can offer accuracy in control and reliability.
by Brent T. Ward & Gerhardt Maurer
August 8, 2019

Hydraulics have long been the go-to solution where mechanical advantage is needed and where an appropriate amount of space is available. However, hydraulics pose a number of challenges that users have historically accepted as a trade-off for the relative simplicity of operation and servicing.

Some of these challenges have to do with the nature of the hydraulic fluids, the required supporting system components and setup, and the failure modes associated with the systems. To address these issues as well as the growing need to decrease size, improve accuracy and deliver high reliability, a new approach has been created.

CLDP servo driveImage 1. CLDP servo drive (Images courtesy of Voith)

The technology uses linear drives that can offer the mechanical advantage of hydraulics, along with accuracy in control and reliability. Solutions are relatively wear-free, pose little to no environmental issues and provide compact solutions for applications with small footprints. These factors make the closed loop differential pump (CLDP) solution a choice for both retrofit and new installations. The CLDP has the ability to remotely notify an operator when it or associated equipment may need attention, as well as the capability of providing insight into the specifics of what attention the equipment requires.

hydraulic-based turbine governor controlImage 2. Traditional hydraulic-based turbine governor control

Configurations

Traditionally, turbine governors regulate water on the principle of interconnected valves, and they require large systems that take up valuable plant floor space. Today, a hydraulic axis control typically consists of a cylinder, a servo valve, electronics and a separate hydraulic unit. These components may be considered plug-and-play in terms of the electronics but not plug-and-play with regard to the system, making the installation and commissioning more time-consuming and complex.

Using a CLDP, a turbine governor can regulate water flow by adjusting the turbine guide vanes. This design results in a more compact unit. The hydraulic regulation is largely environmentally friendly and energy efficient. The drive unit leverages the principles of a servo-hydraulic linear drive CLDP, which can be successful in a wide range of applications. Due to low wear and long service life in continuous-use applications, this design is also used in sectors such as the food industry, test rigs and laboratory machines.

CLDP configurationImage 3. CLDP configuration diagram.
CLDP controlImage 4. Functional block diagram of CLDP control

Some of the demonstrated benefits of the CLDP approach include:

  • power density
  • flexibility and configurability
  • compact size
  • energy efficiency
  • resiliency

The linear drive with the servo pump and servo inverter can provide pressure and position control when operating the linear axis. The control loop is closed using an integrated or external travel measuring system or a pressure sensor. A separate hydraulic drive unit is unnecessary for axis operation. Eliminating the valves reduces system complexity and with closed loop systems, the filtration and cooling systems are eliminated.

CLDP equipmentImage 5. Configuration options for CLDP equipment.

Operation, Safety & Reliability

Depending on the space and configuration of equipment, the CLDP-based equipment can be arranged in a number of ways, as depicted in Image 5 on page 37.

One hydropower station on a remote island that has a CLDP-based turbine governor installed offers a capacity of approximately 2 megawatts (MW) and is equipped with two turbines.

As part of an extensive upgrade, the power plant installed two new turbines, each fitted with a control unit. The CLDP-based equipment allowed it to be readily integrated into existing systems, even where space was tight. The self-contained system of the autonomous compact drive did not require additional piping, the control unit did not require an additional accumulator and it works with a low volume of hydraulic fluid. These factors allow for safer operation without fluid losses, making it environmentally friendly. Regular checks and inspections could be discontinued.

In remote facilities, these features represented cost savings along with enhanced service. The system was preassembled at the manufacturer, so the installation and commissioning at the site was kept to a minimum.

Connectivity, Monitoring & Optimization

As part of the CLDP equipment, controllers and sensors are provided for position, pressure and other parameters that provide feedback for proper, accurate and responsive control. Additionally, other sensing equipment can be combined to provide a holistic view of the operation of the equipment both on-site and off-site. This information can provide real-time information, alerts and alarms should any of the equipment begin to trend outside of normal operating condition—indicating a potential issue.

When connected for remote monitoring, computing capabilities—such as those in the cloud—can perform advanced analytics, machine learning, predictive algorithms and anomaly detection, providing information about the current operation and potential set points or remedies for improved efficiencies or to avert catastrophic failures.

Ultimately, information from the turbine governor and other systems can provide a comprehensive operational picture for the facility or enterprise and enable options to more automatically shift loads, adjust to market demands and provide greater insights.

Conclusion

Some possible additional benefits of the CLDP-based approach include:

  • flexibility for conversion ratios
  • functionality like a wear-free gearbox
  • precision-improved accuracy and control
  • overload protection
  • integration of the volume compensator

This type of design provides availability in remote sites that need to run for long periods of time without service. In addition, remote monitoring technology provides real-time information with ongoing insights and indications should there be a change in operations—thus ensuring notifications when or if needed and information provided about the source of any issues.