Common Pumping Mistakes

My July 2016 article (“Are You a Pump Ninja?”, see it here) was in the format of a quiz. The quiz was very popular with readers, so I have been asked to follow up with a few more questions. Before I present a new series of questions, I have some comments regarding the July issue’s quiz.

For the record, I was not the one who picked the operative title word of “ninja.” Apologies to the editors, but I took a lot of ribbing from several of my fellow pump engineers. (Editor’s note: We are really glad to hear about the great response!)

Many of you wrote to me for explanations, comments and critique, and for that interest I sincerely thank you. The following discussion provides clarification on a few of the July quiz questions.

## Doubling Pump Speed

Question No. 2 referenced an example of doubling the pump speed to examine a fundamental knowledge of the affinity laws, but I did not add the caveat to essentially ignore the system pipe friction for this question. My thinking was that the next question on pipe size changes would make the point clear. A better way to state this would be a quote from William McNally: “The affinity laws predict pump performance changes, not changes in pump/system interactions. You’ll have to plot your ‘before and after’ pump curves with your system curve to estimate where your pump will operate.”

In the real world, doubling the speed on an existing and installed pump would produce some serious issues. The motor would need to be replaced by one capable of at least eight times the previous horsepower, which would require a bigger baseplate and potentially a whole new foundation. The electrical power lines would be too small to handle the new load, and the conduit would need to be upsized. In addition, the motor starter and controller would have to be replaced/upsized (see Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers [IEEE] and National Electrical Manufacturers Association [NEMA] codes).

The fluid friction increases with the square of the flow rate (Darcy-Weisbach/Colebrook formulas), so the required system head would increase dramatically.

See Equations 1 and 2 for examples that complement the affinity laws. Equation 1 demonstrates that the system friction curve varies as the capacity ratio squared, while Equation 2 shows that the system friction loss is inversely proportional to the pipe diameter ratio to the fifth power.

As an example using Equation 1, assume the initial flow was 200 gallons per minute (gpm) through a pipe system and the resultant friction loss is 18 feet. Increasing the flow to 350 gpm will result in a new friction value of 55 feet.

As an example using Equation 2, assume a system with 4-inch pipe can handle a flow rate of 500 gpm. The friction was calculated and checked empirically to be 20 feet of friction loss. If the system pipe size is reduced to 3-inch pipe, the new friction loss would be 84 feet.

## Suction Lift

Question No. 7 on a theoretical suction lift calculated at sea level while pumping water at a temperature of 70 F also elicited discussion. The question’s wording implied that the reader could simply ignore the real-world losses of friction, recirculation, shock losses and possible air ingress leakage. Yes, the theoretical lift would be 33.95 feet depending on barometric pressure (33.95 feet was the correct answer for the question), but in the real world, on an average installation, you will be lucky to get 25 feet of lift.

## Discharge Valve Position

Regarding question No. 23, when starting a centrifugal pump, the discharge valve can be in the closed position. Some procedures require this, and with smaller pumps, it is not overly difficult to open the valve after the pump is started. With larger pumps, it may be difficult or impossible to open the valve because of the high differential pressure across the valve.

If there are pumps in parallel and/or there is pressure from other sources on one side of the isolation valve, the differential pressure has to be reduced or equalized to facilitate opening the valve. Some designers incorporate a small bypass valve to initially balance the pressure so the main valve can be opened easily. The correct answer was “d.” It depends on the specific speed, the system design and the operating procedures.

No matter how you start the pump, you must minimize the time that the pump operates at zero or low flow.

## More Questions to Test Your Knowledge

Take this quiz and write down your answers. Then find out if you are a true Pump Ninja by referencing the answer key here.

Select the answer that is most correct.

1. Given a specific fluid to be pumped, at what viscosity range should you begin to apply viscous corrections to the hydraulic performance for a centrifugal pump?
A) 5 to 15 centipoise
B) Above 300 centipoise
C) Above 600 centipoise
D) centrifugal pumps do not require viscosity corrections.